+- Historic Shooting Forums (http://historicshooting.com)
+-- Forum: General (http://historicshooting.com/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Reloading (http://historicshooting.com/forum-4.html)
+---- Forum: Paper Patch (http://historicshooting.com/forum-41.html)
+---- Thread: Baco 438470 (/thread-3260.html)
RE: Baco 438470 - Don McDowell - 11-21-2022
Jim I lifted this picture Ian posted on another forum of some bullets he fired into a swimming pool
RE: Baco 438470 - Kurt - 11-21-2022
Jim,
It makes no difference what your chamber is, GG or a tighter PP chamber how a bore diameter patched in a tight or standard chamber for GG. The bullet will leave the muzzle looking like the first photo bullet does.
Yes the patched bullet to bore diameter in a loose chamber will expand fitting the chamber wall but it will get reduced back to bore and groove diameter and it will look like #1 again. That bullet was fired in a standard Shiloh chamber that will handle a GG if I chose to use one.
Deep seating an over sized projectile will shoot well but you loose the powder room in a say small case. I have projectile that will patch to bore or groove and both work just fine but the effect you might find using a oversized projectile when it gets swaged back down with a chamber to large in diameter where the inside of the case wall is wider than the grooves are deep you will develop finns at the base and it makes no difference with what sort of wads or alloy temper your using. If the bullet is too large for the bore/groove the lead will get pushed back down when it enters the lead and lands will swage the fin. It makes no difference using a PP or GG.
The only advantage I see using a bullet patched to groove diameter is when the chamber has a lot of freebore than the patched to groove will shine. I have and had rifles with excess freenbore and in those chambers I use a groove diameter bullet or one of Arnies DDEPP design and they smile in a long free bore chamber also in a regular chamber as long as it does not get patched wider than groove depth.
Jim and I spent time at matches and discussed bullet designs quite often and both of us had the agreement that the blunter nosed projectiles where more forgiving at extended ranges like the #1 in photo #2 and also it has held me high at the gong shoots and silhouette matches. They are more forgiving we found when the winds get up.
Alloy and wad stacks make a difference also how a bullet gets distorted from obturation. A bullet patched at bore diameter with a soft alloy will fair better than a hard when using felt or cork.
I have spent way too much time studding what happens to bullets settling my curiosity and founds a lot of head scratchers wondering why
those are 3# coffee cans full of curiosity bullets plus a 5 gallon bucket full that also melted back down into 10# ingots, Best you hit the range and what works best for you. Yes you will end up with many moulds if your like most of us.
Kurt
RE: Baco 438470 - Tgc - 12-07-2022
Kurt, excellent, informative post. The super secret, super duty mold was delivered this afternoon. I ordered it from Baco the Friday before Thanksgiving, received a call and a email from Dave on Tuesday before Thanksgiving and it was delivered today. I think that is awesome service for a custom design and sized mold. Thank you Dave and Buffalo arms company. Tim.
RE: Baco 438470 - Kurt - 12-07-2022
Tim,
That bullet should do well with your rifles .200" freebore it has. It will be seated a little deeper but it should make a fine gas seal with its long DD.
I favor that bullet ogive. When Dave started making moulds him and Jim both gave me a call asking about what I favored for a ogive design and this is what I said I like using. and he made several for me with that ogive for the .40 and .44. I even have a swage die made for my Walnut Hill Richard Corbin swage press.
I use it for target and hunting.
I used that nose design at a full-size iron Buffalo at 1585 yards using the .44-77 Shiloh with the long Lawrence barrel sights with room to reach a few hundred yards farther.
I will be waiting to see your results when it gets a little warmer.
RE: Baco 438470 - Tgc - 12-07-2022
Kurt, I really appreciate you sharing your experience and knowledge with the forum. I will keep you posted when I get some shooting done. Thanks. Tim
RE: Baco 438470 - Kurt - 12-08-2022
Dave must have his guys working overtime. I ordered a mould on the 5th of Dec. and it came last night already. Now to cut new patches for this block of iron.